Appeal to LNC Judicial Committee
www.allpartysystem.com/Appeal-to-LNC-Judicial-Committee.php
About LNC Judicial Committee
Click here to see 1996 FEC Form 2, FEC-2-7-1996-(4).pdf
http://www.allpartysystem.com/FEC-2-7-1996-(4).pdf
See the copies of the original 34 paper ballots cast and kept as proof since 2019:
JPGs of Paper Ballots
www.allpartysystem.com/Appeal-to-LPLAC-JC.php
URGENT Appeal for Motion to Adopt new Guidelines and Call for Vote of Confidence to All of LNC
By James Ogle [One], Pure Proportional Representation (PPR) Electoral College
8/14/2020
To: mary@ruwart dot com
Cc: arnldtcj@aol dot com
agmattson@gmail dot com
jim@jimturney dot com
chuck@moulton dot org
dfrank_robinson@yahoo dot com
crazycircusdogs@yahoo dot com
robert.kraus@lp dot org
* * *
Principle and Bylaw Violations
Principle Violated
By the LNC (under "Representative Government")
"We oppose laws that effectively exclude alternative candidates and parties, deny
ballot access, gerrymander districts, or deny the voters their right to consider
all legitimate alternatives."
Source:
https://www.lp.org/platform
NOTE: The insider bosses kept the LP voters from hearing about all 60+ Prez and
VP nominees. Instead of equal time and equal treatment the bosses deleted and censored.
Bylaw Violated
By the LNC (under "ARTICLE 2: PURPOSES Line 2.")
"2. electing Libertarians to public office to move public policy in a libertarian direction."
Source:
https://www.lp.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/2018-
Indexed-LP-Bylaws-and-Convention-Rules-w-2016-JC-Rules-2.pdf?fbclid=IwAR1amfe-i7UBxNusVeYHlrJghAJ5IDnK03n8nqN2DYgTh7mUAFKTBFpljZI
NOTE: Nobody in America wants a one-party system and that is violation
of Article 2, purpose line two, libertarians winning elections. The LNC brings
a dictatorship psychology to American voters and nobody buys it because
one-party voting systems are no good. That's the LNC violating the purpose of winning by instead guaranteeing losses.
* * *
Be it known that James Ogle requests that the LNC Judicial Committee overturn the nominations of Prez and VP.
The LNC shall conduct an election among all nominees for Prez, VP and Electors, all titles simultaneously,
538 names ranked #1 to #538 where each name picks titles starting with #1 who may pick the title US President
and/or Chair and the top two ranked names pick first and only President and Vice President may pick a second
title such as Chair or Vice Chair.
Paper ballots can use the "party list system" or the blank "write-in paper ballot":
https://www.allpartysystem.com/e-aps-13.pdf Write-in PDF
https://www.allpartysystem.com/e-aps-13.pdf Party-list PDF
The new "votes of confidence" are described below in item 4., and these new rules allow perpetual votes of
confidence for all the executives by each and every one of the 538 Presidential Electors and items of Unity
Platform USA, through December 31st 2020.
* * *
Libertarian National Committee (LNC), Libertarian Party of California and Libertarian Party of Los Angeles County
1) Libertarian National Committee (LNC)
2) Libertarian Party of California
3) Libertarian Party of Los Angeles County
4) Votes on New Rules and New Votes of Confidence
* * *
1) Libertarian National Committee (LNC)
2020 LNC used digital ballots in single-winner district, plurality voting (or RCV?) using "rounds" = one-party system
2020 No proof of paper ballots
Violation of Principles
https://www.lp.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/2018-Indexed-LP-Bylaws-and-Convention-Rules-w-2016-JC-Rules-2.pdf
d. voiding of National Committee decisions (Article 7, Section 12),
g. suspension of Presidential and Vice-Presidential candidates (Article 14, Section 5).
Appeal to both LNC Judicial Committee for Following Violations
2012 LP convention Paper ballots using single-winner district plurality voting (or RCV?)
using "rounds" = one-party system
2020 LP convention used digital ballots in single-winner election district plurality
voting (or RCV?) using "rounds" = one-party system
2020 LP convention didn't allow all names on ballot in Zoom "debates" = censorship of
candidates and Delegates have no information about nominees.
2020 LP convention censored close to 60 LP Prez candidates who filed Form Two, fewer
than ten spoke in final debate.
2020 LP convention allowed two(?) names for Vice President while all Electors' names
were blocked from ballots used in Zoom calls.
2020 LP convention prohibited Prez and VP candidates in the same debate so to
demonstrate teamwork and other traits which Delegates might seem appropriate in Zoom call.
2020 LP convention harmed teamwork and cross communication and pair-tests between
candidates for Prez and VP.
2020 National Libertarian Party Chair, Vice Chair and all LNC Executive Elections
2020 No proof of paper ballots
Digital ballots using single-winner and multiple-winner districts under plurality and
approval (AppV) voting = one-party system
Thresholds for Judicial Committee used pluralities, the top seven vote-getters were
winners, and not Droop Quota.
In a seven-winner judicial seat election the Droop Quota could be 12.5% (plus one vote)
and satisfaction level 87.5%.
Platform items were voted on using yes/no as options (two-party system).
Chair, Vice Chair, Secretary and Treasurer were elected as single-winner election
districts (one-party system).
All Executive seats must be elected at-large as one 16-member (Droop threshold = 5.8%
plus one vote) or 17-member (Droop threshold = 5.5% plus one vote) election district.
One-party and two-party voting systems used are unacceptable because America is a
melting pot.
The results of blocking/censoring Presidential and Vice Presidential candidates failed
the delegates because they didn't know names and messages from all candidates and a large number
were kept off the official Zoom Call speaking, voting and ballots.
2020 National Libertarian Party Chair, Vice Chair and all LNC Executive Elections
Digital ballots using single-winner and multiple-winner districts under plurality and
approval (AppV) voting = one-party system
One-party and two-party voting systems used are unacceptable because America is a melting pot.
The results of blocking/censoring Presidential and Vice Presidential candidates failed
the delegates because they didn't know names and message from all candidates and a large
number were kept off the official Zoom Call speaking, voting and ballots.
* * *
2) Libertarian Party of California
Our team (Horst/Ogle for Prez/Vice Prez [Libertarian/One]) announced in 2018 as both US
Prez/VP, and one as candidate for State at-large CA L.P. Executive, appellate was deleted
from California State LP Facebook page and never reinstated and the reason might be
censorship(?). Blocked by slate.
2020 CA LP convention made a clerical error kept James Ogle's name off ballot electing
delegates
2020 California State LP Convention used paper ballots with multiple-winners under
approval voting (AppV) = one-party system for selecting six of twelve qualified Prez and
VP candidates including three first-time home-state names and three who flew from East
Coast USA, all were present in audience. But they were blocked by quick AppV by Chair.
2020 Paper ballots using 107-winner district plurality voting for LNC Delegates =
semi-proportional system so individuals attending were blocked by slate vote.
Violations to Libertarian Party of California Bylaws:
https://ca.lp.org/committees/
Judicial Committee counted votes incorrectly and refused the right to appeal.
Chairperson – David Bowers
judicial@ca.lp.org
Bylaws Committee Contacted and confirmed by Bylaws Chair
Members pending.
Contact Email – bylaws@ca.lp.org
2020 California LP Convention Paper ballots using 107-winner district plurality voting for LNC Delegates = semi-proportional system
Clerical error kept Presidential candidate James Ogle off the ballot at California State LP convention
for electing Delegates to national Zoom call.
One-party, two-party and semi-proportional voting systems used are unacceptable because America is a melting pot.
* * *
3) Libertarian Party of Los Angeles County
2020 Los Angeles County Libertarian Party Web Page
https://lplac.us/
2020 Los Angeles County Libertarian Party Web Page
https://lplac.us/resources/bylaws/file/32-2019-lplac-bylaws
ARTICLE V: OFFICERS
Section 1: Officers and Duties. The officers of the Party shall be a Chair, a Vice-Chair, a Secretary,
a Treasurer, and Regional Representative from each Region.
Section 2: Elections, Term of Office. The officers shall be elected by ballot to serve for one year or
until their successors are elected, and their term of office shall begin at the close of the annual meeting
at which they are elected. Nominations shall be from the floor.
Section 3: Interim Removal and Appointment of Officers. A County Officer may be removed from Office by a
two-thirds (2/3) vote of the Executive Board after failure to attend two (2) consecutive board meetings. In
the case of an interim vacancy of County Office, the Executive Board shall have the power to appoint a member
to that office upon a majority vote at a regular Executive Board meeting.
Section 4: Office-Holding Limitations. No member shall hold more than one office at a time.
Bylaw Item violated was #ARTICLE V: OFFICERS, Section 2.
Ogle was elected at the annual July 5th 2020 convention as a tie and was reportedly removed as Regional Rep at
the 2nd virtual meeting.
July 5th 2020 Violations of Liberty 2020 Chair
Bylaw Items #
The 2020 paper ballots were smaller than business card and were destroyed immediately after election results so
no second count can be made in 2020. Blocked by the biggest "slate".
The same volunteers might also be part of continually enlargement of censorship and one-party system voting by
the "Porcupine Vote Program"(?) being used in LA, CA and USA levels.
The programmers don't use Droop Quota and that snuffing out of competition protects the one-party "insiders".
The United Coalition is resolving this by working with Sarah Revard [Libertarian] so to unite the guidelines of the
Los Angeles County Mini-state and the Los Angeles County Libertarian Party within Region 62.
* * *
2019 Los Angeles County Libertarian Party
Judicial Committee counted votes incorrectly and refused right to appeal.
Chairperson – David Bowers
After the 2019 LPLAC JC election, the original 34 paper ballots were obtained and kept as proof by appellate, and the
copies show that James Ogle's name won 33.33% of votes after the single-transfer of two votes, due to resignation of previous winner of seat.
James Ogle's name won 33.33% of votes on JC as shown from paper ballots cast that same day and now available as proof.
See the copies of the original 34 paper ballots cast and kept as proof since 2019:
JPGs of Paper Ballots
www.allpartysystem.com/Appeal-to-LPLAC-JC.php
* * *
4) Votes on New Rules and New Votes of Confidence
2020 Los Angeles County Mini-state (ss11-9) http://www.allpartysystem.com/e-aps-22-marked.php
Marked Paper Ballot #e-aps-22 by James Ogle on 8/6/2020:
1. Ranked choice voting (RCV): All voting and vote counting shall be in the form of ranked paper ballots only (and eballots
when practical and verifiable).
Consecutive numbers beginning with the #s 1, 2, 3, 4, etc. etc. must always be used when marking on (e)ballot of all names
and decision-items. Deviation from this guideline #1 will disqualify the ballot, and the ballot will be marked "SPOILED",
separated from the stack of ballots with numerical purity and only the pure stack after being separated from the spoiled
ballots are considered democratically legit.
2. Election of Names Under Pure Proportional Representation (PPR) - The Election of names are only held in multiple-winner
election districts of two or more only using limited voting with no exceptions.
Limited voting using "Xs" brings semi-proportional results and limited voting using ranked choice votes (RCV) brings pure
proportional representation (PPR).
Limited voting is used where there are fewer votes cast per voter than there are open seats at-large. By using ranked choice
voting (RCV) each paper ballot is one whole vote, one-man-per-vote and each uses the single transferable vote (STV).
There are two equations involved that are used for PPR. First is the Hagenbach-Bishoff Method with the Hare or Droop Quotas and the
second is the single transferable vote (STV).
3. Elections of Decision-items - Many decision-items may be ranked simultaneously to save time and that's where each numeral starting
with #1 is like one whole vote. Any item attaining 50% plus one vote or more is considered approved "by the team".
In decision-making items, ranked choice voting (RCV) is always used, with no exceptions.
There is no STV when using RCV with decision-items.
In cases of ties, we add the sum of all numerals (or "tics"), and the item(s) in a tie with the lowest sum of rankings gets prioritized
above items with larger sums of the rankings. This system is known as "Ogle Method" or "Count the Tics".
* * *